While procrastinating last week, I did what we all do, I scrolled around on my phone instead of doing something meaningful. “Skinny Jeans Are Back,” the Huffington Post article was titled in my Apple News and I rolled my eyes and clicked the link which was linked to a Vogue article that started by saying, “Denim whisperers have been predicting a skinny jean revival for some time.” Later that day, while doing some shopping for a client, I saw low-rise jeans being sold on the J.Crew website. “What alternative universe are we living in?” I wondered.
I realize that trends come and go. Just a few years ago, we were asked to reconsider bootcut jeans and it wasn’t long ago that there was a funny SNL skit about mom jeans, the exact style many women sartorially now have en masse in their closets. No, my issue isn’t that jeans trends cycle, it’s why we even adhere to the concept of the one-trend-at-a-time jeans trend.
JEANS SHOULD BE LIKE SALAD DRESSING
The average grocery store stocks 300 different salad dressings at one time. If this post were about salad dressing, I’d argue how unnecessarily insane that is, but this isn’t about salad dressing, it’s that if we have 300 different options for dressing a salad on average, why are women supposed to wear one jean shape at a time, especially considering that we choose salad dressing for about the same reasons we choose jeans shapes. Sometimes, we prefer a certain salad dressing because some salads demand a lighter zingier dressing, like a crisp vinaigrette, while other salads pair better with a heavier blue cheese. Then there are those people who don’t care what the salad is, they’re going to plop Ranch dressing on it. Other people like variety and go with Thousand Island one day and honey mustard the next, and certainly dietary restrictions and food allergies inform the types of salad dressings other people choose.
What could be said for salad dressing could absolutely be said about jeans. Jeans choices can be determined by outfit, like a skinny with tall boots or a wider leg with a slim or cropped top. Or by preference; some people just like what they like and find their preferred leg shape and choose their outfits based on that. And relatively similar to food restrictions, some people just can’t wear certain jeans shapes or rises. The point is, shouldn’t the jeans we choose to wear be based on something more substantial than what is trending?
This is really more a rhetorical question because it’s a question that fashion should be answering, not us. However, despite the trend forecasters in the sky predicting the future of jeans, I was encouraged to see that along with low-rise jeans on the J.Crew websites, a person could still buy mid and high-rise jeans. It should also be noted that despite skinny jeans going by the wayside for quite a few years now, they never completely left the stores. Despite there being specific jeans trends, retailers have diversified. So the question really should bounce back to us, the consumers. Isn’t it time we stop following supposed jeans trends and choose to wear styles that suit us best?
THE LIFECYCLE OF A TREND IS EXCEPTIONALLY SHORT
You’re likely old enough to remember when trends lasted a lot longer than they do now. Bootcut jeans were not only popular from the late 90s and into the early 2000s but they were just about the only jeans silhouette women wore. Skinny jeans then started to become popular by the mid-2000s and held strong for over a decade. Whether women liked wearing them or not or regardless of whether they looked flattering, it was skinny jeans or nothing. Times like this don’t really exist any longer because the life cycle of a trend is now exceptionally short. As consumers, we need to adjust not just to the mentality of lightening fashion trends but what we choose to do with this change as a result.
The ruling thought as to why trends don’t last as long as they used to is because of fast fashion and the rise of social media. Speed to market, the cycle that fashion goes from concept to market, has been cut down considerably compared to what it used to be. The old model was somewhere between 26 and 40 weeks. Now, companies can do this in as little as six weeks, sometimes less. Next, social media. According to this McKinsey study, social media allows retailers to use advanced recognition tools to identify styles and colors trending on social media. While it feels very big brother, it allows retailers to hone in on consumer interest in a way that was not possible before.
OF COURSE, THIS POSES A NEW PROBLEM— TOO MANY CHOICES
On the flip side, while the variety can feel refreshing and inclusive, it isn’t without a downfall because now with this blessing of variety you have to navigate all the choices presented. A paradox of choice means when the number of choices increases, so does the difficulty of knowing what is best. Instead of increasing the freedom to have what you want, the paradox of choice suggests that having too many choices actually limits your freedom. Barry Schwartz, psychologist and author of the book, Paradox of Choice: Why Less is More, says that too many choices take time and energy, even when you know what you’re looking for. A culture of abundance can rob you of satisfaction because you can slip into analysis paralysis and gain less satisfaction from your choices. When there is more to choose from it is easier to imagine an alternative potentially making you happier. Lastly, when more choices are presented, the responsibility falls on you to figure out the best choice which can feel like a lot when the average person already makes approximately 30,000-35,000 decisions a day.
We may complain that fashion dictates like a bunch of evil cult leaders, but when you look at it from this perspective and what too much choice potentially robs from us, why being told what to wear still appeal to so many. It’s not so much the trend forecasts that we’re drawn to as it is the fact that someone is deciding for us and of our mental bandwidth isn’t sacrificed.
WHERE DOES THIS LEAVE US?
I think where we are left goes back to what I said earlier, that jeans shapes and rises we wear should be determined by something more substantial than solely what trend forecasters predict because given how quickly things change, you will spend your time and money trying to keep up, paralyzed by indecision and overwhelmed by choice. Find trends that suit you and you prefer and then build your wardrobe around that.


Dear Skinny Pants,
Please go away and never come back! 😉
I am definitely most certain that you are no alone in this sentiment.
Yes, like salad dressing!
My best profile: long over skinny.
will never give ’em up. EVER. I’ll be buying vintage skinny until I’m in the nursing home and by then they’ll be forcing baggy sweats on me.
Never lol
I’m so tired of jeans that do only one thing or another to extremes: super high rise, super wide leg, super skinny, super flared, super distressed, super whiskered, super tapered, super long. I just want a pair of dark blue, mid-size, straight jeans that don’t bag out after 30 minutes. Simple yet impossible to find.